San Diego Utilities: City Resolutions Challenge SDG&E Rate Hikes and Franchise
Local governments in San Diego and Chula Vista voted to formally oppose an 8.5% utility bill increase while exploring the feasibility of a public power system.
By Giulia Liu ·

Two separate city resolutions are challenging San Diego Gas & Electric, targeting both a proposed rate increase and the utility's long-term franchise in the region. The San Diego City Council Environment Committee passed a measure on Thursday supporting the exploration of a municipal utility. Simultaneously, Chula Vista is preparing to vote on a resolution opposing a rate hike filed with the California Public Utilities Commission.
SDG&E has requested a general rate case that would increase revenue by approximately 8% to cover maintenance and upgrades from 2028 to 2031. If the commission approves the request in full, typical residential customers not enrolled in the California Alternate Rates for Energy program would see their combined electric and gas bills rise by 8.5% compared to 2027 levels.
Chula Vista Mayor John McCann argued that residents are already under financial strain. He told reporters at a press conference outside City Hall that families do not need a large increase in their monthly electricity bills. McCann plans to present the resolution to the city council on December 8.
Shane Harris, founder of the Office of the San Diego Public Advocate, urged local leaders to adopt formal resolutions against the proposal. Harris stated that these measures commit city lobbying resources to oppose the change, including sending letters to the California PUC on behalf of Chula Vista's 283,000 residents.
In San Diego, the Environment Committee voted 2-1 to advance a resolution supporting affordability and workforce protection. The measure urges the city to take foundational steps toward creating its own utility to replace SDG&E within city limits. Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, who chairs the committee, said residents are tired of the relationship and want a clear path forward.
A 202-page analysis by NewGen Strategies & Solutions, Siemens, and another firm concluded that a municipal electric-only utility is technically and financially feasible. The study projected annual savings of over $600 million after 30 years, equating to $500 per customer, though it noted the projections remain theoretical. SDG&E countered that its own analysis suggests bills would initially rise with no meaningful savings for decades.
The San Diego resolution emphasizes that union employees are essential to any transition. It states that any move forward must guarantee existing pay, benefits, seniority, pensions, and collective bargaining rights. Nate Fairman, business manager at IBEW Local 465, warned the committee earlier in the year that if the transition fails, the public and workers would bear the cost.
Councilmember Jennifer Campbell voted against the resolution, arguing that the primary oversight role belongs to the California PUC. She expressed hope that the new governor would appoint commission members willing to firmly regulate investor-owned utilities. The committee vote was joined by City Council President Joe LaCava.
San Diego operates under a 20-year franchise agreement approved in 2021, which allows the city to opt out after 10 years if it establishes a municipal utility. San Francisco is currently evaluating a similar exit from Pacific Gas & Electric. The two cities are in a dispute over the value of PG&E's infrastructure, with the city estimating it at $3.4 billion and PG&E claiming the figure is closer to $22.5 billion.
The California PUC held public participation hearings in Santee on Tuesday regarding the SDG&E rate proposal. The meetings drew overflow crowds, with many attendees speaking against any increase. The commission expects to issue a proposed decision on the rate case late next year, after which its five voting members will review the request.






